State Audit Reveals Widespread Mismanagement in Alabama Prisons

11.19.26

ADOC

State auditors have released an extensive report documenting weak leadership and severe mismanagement in the Alabama Department of Corrections and calling for “a fundamental change of culture at the agency.”

The 367-page report published on November 6 by the Alabama Department of Examiners of Public Accounts is the first state-ordered audit of Alabama’s broken prison system, which goes on trial this month in a federal lawsuit filed by the U.S. Justice Department.

In April 2019, the Justice Department notified ADOC and Gov. Kay Ivey that Alabama was violating the Constitution by failing to protect prisoners from physical violence and sexual abuse. A second letter sent in July 2020 notified state officials that a pattern of excessive force by officers and a lack of accountability of those officers similarly violates the Constitution.

Federal prosecutors filed a lawsuit against ADOC in December 2020 to enforce the constitutional rights of people incarcerated in Alabama. Trial is set to begin on November 30 and is expected to last two months.

In the seven and a half years since the Justice Department’s original findings, the crisis in Alabama’s prisons has continued unabated. ADOC’s own data records more than 1,600 deaths of people incarcerated in state prisons between April 2019 and June 2026.

At least 100 of these deaths were violent homicides by incarcerated people and officers; hundreds more were due to suicide or drug overdose. In 2023, nearly half of all recorded deaths in ADOC custody were due to homicide, suicide, or fatal overdose.

Family members of incarcerated people have pleaded with state lawmakers for years, flooding their offices with calls reporting their loved ones had been extorted, beaten, stabbed, raped, or killed in Alabama’s prisons. Legislators responded by ordering ADEPA to conduct an audit of ADOC facilities.

For ADEPA’s first pilot audit of ADOC, examiners reviewed ADOC’s Central Office in Montgomery as well as Kilby Correctional Facility, a maximum-security prison in Montgomery that houses approximately 1,400 men.

“An Underlying Sense of Secrecy” in ADOC’s Central Office

Auditors assessing ADOC’s organizational culture encountered unusual barriers to accessing records and state personnel that “raised red flags” during the review. ADEPA was forced to take extraordinary measures and issue a subpoena to obtain certain records that it said should be readily available at any state agency.

“There appears to be an underlying sense of secrecy within the agency,” the report found, as well as “a significant disregard for the oversight functions that are essential to ensuring transparency, accountability, and effective governance within ADOC and the prison system.”

A central finding of the auditor’s review of ADOC’s Central office was that the department’s leadership fails to ensure that staff are given appropriate policies to fulfill their responsibilities and does not set the expectation that policies will be enforced consistently with consequences for failure. Instead, auditors found an institutional culture where employees are not held accountable for ignoring clear internal policy.

For example, auditors pointed to a 2024 state law that requires ADOC to create and operate a Constituent Services Department to respond to inquiries and complaints from families of incarcerated people.

“The law is clear there should be procedures in place for employees to adhere to,” the auditors found, but ADOC has not created procedures “concerning how to handle constituent services inquiries or submissions.” As a result, “it was unclear who, if anyone, is responsible for ensuring all emails are addressed and properly logged.”

Even where ADOC has written regulations pertaining to the management of facilities and inmate welfare, the audit found those policies are ignored without consequences for staff, but at significant cost to prisoners, their families, and the public.

“There was a general lack of understanding of what the [regulations and policies] state and what was actually taking place at both central office and at the facility,” the auditors found. “Numerous times throughout this review, key central office staff referenced what the [regulations] stated, and their reference was either inaccurate or was not the actual procedure taking place at the facility.”

Other major findings include:

  • Weak central oversight of prison staff and facility operation

“[W]ritten requirements did not always align with actual practices, employees were not consistently aware of where policies and procedures were maintained, policy revisions were not always effectively communicated, and facilities sometimes interpreted or implemented the same requirements differently.”

  • Systemic failures in reporting and case management

“Different ADOC units frequently report conflicting information … Additionally, management often lacks reliable data to assess performance, identify problems, and make informed decisions.”

  • Lack of staff accountability

ADOC demonstrated “weaknesses in surveillance activities, inconsistent disciplinary processes, limited access to programming, delays in reentry preparation, informal grievance administration, and challenges in consistently implementing policies and procedures.”

  • Failure to provide essential rehabilitative services

Auditors “identified deteriorating infrastructure, inconsistent access to basic services, limited programming opportunities, and ineffective communication mechanisms across facilities. These conditions were associated with increased health and safety concerns, challenges in supervision and service delivery, and shortcomings in program participation and reentry preparation.”

Risks to “Overall Safety and Security” at Kilby Correctional Facility

Auditors found that deficiencies in leadership at the Central Office were connected to weak management practices at Kilby that increased the risk to “the overall safety and security of the facility, staff and inmates.” These practices include systematic mismanagement in the following operations at Kilby:

  • Video camera monitoring

Auditors found that the prison’s video camera system was “fully operational and functioning properly” but no staff were monitoring the system. Staff responsible for security operations at the prison either had no access to the system or did not know how to access the system. At the off-site monitoring room at ADOC’s Central Office, auditors “found the room unattended, with no one monitoring cameras for ADOC facilities statewide. A handwritten note on the door read, ‘Be back soon.’” When ADEPA and ADOC staff attempted to locate the individual, they discovered the officer in another area of ADOC Central Office folding inmate uniforms.

  • Investigation of sexual assault

The auditors found systemic violations of ADOC policy on sexual assault and violations of the federal Prison Rape Elimination Act. The report found that of the 100 sexual assault cases reported at Kilby between October 1, 2023, and September 30, 2025, ADOC had no record of investigations in seven of these cases. In the vast majority of these cases, no video evidence was retained by ADOC investigators, and in a third of these cases, no video footage was ever collected. Further, in 20% of these cases ADOC did not document the results of the sexual assault forensic examiner kit. In over 70% of these cases, ADOC did not document whether the victim was referred to or received mental health care.

  • Investigation of deaths

Auditors identified numerous systemic deficiencies in investigating, reporting, and tracking deaths of incarcerated people. “The data tracking for inmate deaths is inconsistent across ADOC. Inconsistencies in data reporting can lead to inaccurate reporting by ADOC creating an environment of ambiguity where transparency is critical.” In their review of death investigation files, auditors identified a pattern of missing documentation, including toxicology reports, next of kin notifications, government death notifications, and initial investigation reports.

  • Excessive use of force investigations

Nearly a third of disciplinary actions documented in employee personnel files at Kilby were not documented in ADOC’s central system, meaning that policies requiring or recommending termination of officers with recent patterns of excessive use of force could not be consistently implemented.

  • Lack of reentry services

Auditors found that Kilby, a facility with 1,400 people, had zero employees dedicated to reentry. Just one person was tasked with assessing the program needs of all newly entering inmates, ordering essential government records for incarcerated people prior to their release, and teaching all rehabilitative workshops. That single employee also reported that the actual need for those workshops, as shown by the number of people who signed up, was six times greater than she could provide, meaning many men at Kilby were unable to receive rehabilitative services before they were transferred or released.

The audit corroborates many of the Justice Department’s findings regarding unconstitutional prison conditions and provides important data for lawmakers and executive leadership as the state faces critical decisions about whether to focus spending and resources on litigation or remedial action.